Thursday, April 03, 2003

Language bullies have a bloody-minded and literal understanding of how speech works.
Not really. Just put the first 'R' back in February and get I/me-us/we straight and there won't be any scenes from me.
Language bullying -- or prescriptivism, as it's more politely called -- is conservative in the worst sense. It advances a stuffy and old-fashioned view of language, the rules of which it considers set by supposed experts, such as the authors of grammar books, rather than common usage. It is deeply anti-populist and snobby, not to mention just plain wrong and cranky....

But worst of all is the constant abuse that is hurled at the non-standard English of blacks and other groups, as when an old Mississippi Delta blues singer howls, "I can't get no lovin'." That's a double negative, bullies say, so it's wrong.
I've been in a fair number of blues bars and have never seen abuse hurled at the musicians. I've never walked out in a snit when someone sings about gettin' no lovin'. But when one of my children says something along the lines of, "He came to visit Fran and I," I do get cranky. Just plain right and cranky.

No comments:


St. Isidore Foundation



I cannot live under pressures from patrons, let alone paint.
-- Michelangelo, quoted in Vasari's Lives of the Artists


Meet the Family...
Collect the Action Figures





Yes, three jade ribbons. 15 Years!
(not all the same child)
If you need to ask, you may not wish to know.


 
Site Meter